Skip to content
Why Applying Online Won’t Get You a Job video with Kael Campbell, Red Seal Recruiting

Why Applying Online Won’t Get You a Job (And What to Do Instead)

Every week, Kael Campbell gets the same request from a customer, an HR contact or a company president: “Can you help my son or daughter who just finished school get a job?” His answer is always the same. Sending hundreds of résumés online is not what gets people hired. Getting out, meeting people and doing real work is.

In this video, Kael breaks down the advice he gives recent graduates, high school leavers and anyone trying to land their first job or apprenticeship.

Why Applying Online Isn’t Enough

Online applications and cold emails feel productive, but they rarely set you apart. When someone walks up to Kael and says, “I’d love to work for your firm” or “I’d like to work in this industry – what is it like?”, his ears perk up right away. That is very different from a random résumé landing in an inbox.

Questions like these get hiring managers talking. They share tips, point you to companies that are hiring and are far more willing to refer you. Sometimes it’s not what you know, it’s who you know – and that means the people you actually build a relationship with, not the number of followers you have on LinkedIn or Facebook.

Take Action: Get “Boots on the Ground”

Kael’s first recommendation for job seekers is to stop starting with “What résumé do I need?” and start talking to people who do the hiring. He also recommends the classic career book What Color Is Your Parachute? – and tells parents not to buy it for their kids. The job seeker has to be the one taking action.

Dress the Part

Part of getting out there is looking like you belong in the job you want – work boots, work shoes or dress shoes, whatever fits the role. You don’t need an expensive wardrobe or designer brands. With a little effort (and a trip to a thrift store), you can make a strong first impression before you say a word:

Get Any Job in or Near Your Field

Kael’s advice is to get working – not in a job that wears you out, but in or close to the field you want, even if that means volunteering at first. Some of the best entry points he sees:

  • Apprenticeships and the skilled trades – electricians get a lot of attention, but carpentry, crane operation, crane mechanics and other construction trades are also strong options.
  • Diesel, heavy duty and automotive mechanics – starting wages are often in the mid-to-high $20s per hour, rising into the $30s, $40s and $50s, with some roles reaching around $70 CAD / $60 USD per hour.
  • Commercial driving – a commercial driver’s licence and a hard job like garbage collection can lead to heavy duty mechanics, power line work, crane work and other heavy machinery roles.
  • Landscaping – available in almost every town, it teaches teamwork, equipment operation, snow clearing and excavating, and proves you know what a hard day’s work is.
  • Marine work – commercial fishing or operating small boats can be a stepping stone toward ship watch roles and, eventually, marine pilot or ferry positions.

An apprenticeship can also offer a better return on investment than a degree: you earn money from day one, and raises or promotions into supervisory roles can follow.

Build Your Network with Hands-On Projects

If you can’t land a role in your target industry yet, create your own experience:

  • Volunteer on a real project, such as helping someone retrofit a boat or a truck.
  • Start a small project of your own (a beater truck or small boat) and document your progress.
  • Post in local Facebook groups and visit local shops to ask for input – and ask whether they know anyone hiring.
  • Book informational interviews to learn what the work is really like and whether it is right for you.

Track Progress, Not Applications

Counting how many applications and cover letters you’ve sent is demoralizing. Instead, keep a diary or a simple spreadsheet, set weekly goals and record your wins: “I connected with 15 people, had coffee with five, and learned how people actually get into this field.” Small daily steps add up – and they lead to a better job faster.

Ready to Start Your Search?

Browse current openings on the Red Seal Recruiting job board, and read our guides on turning a rejection into your next offer and optimizing your LinkedIn profile.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why doesn’t applying online get me a job?

Online applications rarely stand out. Hiring managers respond far more to people who reach out directly, ask good questions and build a relationship, which often leads to referrals.

What is the best first job for someone with no experience?

Any job in or close to your target field. Apprenticeships, landscaping, commercial driving and entry-level mechanic or marine roles all build skills and prove you can work hard.

Is an apprenticeship better than a university degree?

It depends on your goals, but apprenticeships let you earn from day one and can lead to high-paying supervisory roles without years of tuition costs.

How should I track my job search?

Track people met, conversations held and lessons learned each week rather than the number of applications sent.

Kael Campbell
Kael CampbellPresident
Kael Campbell

Kael Campbell has extensive experience working in BC, Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba’s forestry, utility, power generation, manufacturing, equipment and transportation industries. From recruiting for permanent unionized and non-union maintenance trades positions to large industrial construction projects Kael’s recruiting has focused on finding the best trades and industrial management from across Canada to fill a position.

Kael Campbell is a Human Resource professional with a Bachelors in Business Administration, a concentration in Human Resource Management and specialization in social psychology. Kael has been a member of BC Human Resources Management Association (BC HRMA) for 13 years. Kael volunteers for BC HRMA primarily leading workshops and writing. Kael has basic skills with German, Irish/Gaelic, and can say hello and Merry Christmas in Danish!

In the community Kael is the Vice President of the Victoria Marine Rescue Society – RCMSAR 35, Secretary of the Victoria Dragon Boat Society, Membership chair of Entrepreneurs Organization Victoria Chapter. Kael often volunteers with the Human Resource Management Association and local universities and colleges helping new graduates and the underemployed with their job search. Kael can often be found enjoying his free time Salmon and Halibut fishing, mountain biking, four wheel drive camping, back country skiing, scuba diving, stand up paddle boarding and exploring B.C. with family.